10 Best Pizzerias In Toronto

Written by Joeri Van Overloop

Toronto's culinary scene offers a slice for every palate, and when it comes to pizza, the city is brimming with options that stand testament to its diversity and quality. From traditional wood-fired pies to innovative toppings that challenge the norm, the pizza landscape in Toronto is as varied as it is flavorful. In my search for the best pizza in Toronto, I've encountered establishments that pride themselves on high-quality ingredients and authentic preparation methods.

The city's pizzerias range from authentic Italian spots like Sugo, which brings a slice of Italy to Toronto, to Pizzeria Libretto, known for its adherence to Neapolitan traditions. Meanwhile, places like Gusto 101 have managed to blend the traditional Roman-style slice with the trendy, creating a dining experience that resonates with contemporary tastes. Given the array of choices, pinpointing the best Toronto pizza is a delicious challenge.

These Toronto restaurants have not only crafted a reputation for excellence but have also embedded themselves into the city's cultural fabric. Whether it's the charming allure of the New York-style slices from Pizzeria Badiali or the stylish, laid-back atmosphere paired with Neapolitan-style pizza at The Parlour, each venue offers a unique take on this beloved dish. It's clear that Toronto's pizza scene is characterized by a passionate commitment to delivering standout culinary experiences.

1. Pizzeria Badiali

When I explore the vibrant pizza scene in Toronto, Pizzeria Badiali undoubtedly commands attention. Located at 181 Dovercourt Rd in the heart of the city's West end, this slice shop is a gem for those craving a taste of classic New York-style pizza.

What sets it apart is the fact that they emphasize carefully sourced and house-made ingredients, ensuring a fresh, authentic experience. The menu by pizza chef Ryan Baddeley features a range of pizzas, from the classic Margherita to more inventive offerings like Vodka Pizza. And despite being in competition with established places like General Assembly, Pizzeria Badiali holds its own, attracting locals with its quality and charm.

Pizza restaurant Badiali is not just about the food; it's about the feel of a neighborhood hangout that respects the craft of pizza making. They keep the atmosphere unpretentious while delivering on flavor.

So when I'm looking for a reliable spot that satisfies my pizza cravings without having to navigate the bustling Ossington strip, Pizzeria Badiali is my go-to. It is the embodiment of the quality and simplicity that I believe every Toronto pizzeria should strive for, creating a harmonious dining experience for any pizza enthusiast.

Contact:

Address: 181 Dovercourt Rd, Toronto, ON M6J 3C6, Canada

Phone: +1 416-531-5555

2. North of Brooklyn Pizzeria

Each time I explore the bustling pizza scene of Toronto, North of Brooklyn Pizzeria stands out as a prominent name, especially for New York-style pizza aficionados. With several locations across the city, they have made a mark with their commitment to providing a genuine New York-style slice experience. I find that their hours of operation are quite accommodating, typically from 12 pm to 10 or 11 pm, ensuring that both lunch and dinner crowds have the opportunity to enjoy their offerings.

What makes their pizza noteworthy is the thin, crisp crust, a hallmark of New York-style pizza, topped with high-quality fresh ingredients such as truffle, pineapple, jalapeno roasted red peppers, black olives, and pickled red onions . Their menu features a variety of pizzas, and the Killer Bee pizza comes highly recommended. It's not just about classic flavors; their culinary creativity shines through in their unique offerings. Their establishment's vibe is casual and friendly, mirroring the no-fuss attitude of a New York style pizzeria.

One thing I always look forward to is the consistent quality of their pizza. It doesn't matter which day you visit; the standards are always upheld. Their staff is friendly and they make sure your experience is pleasant. If you're in Toronto and have a craving for New York-style pizza, I'd recommend giving North of Brooklyn a try.

Contact:

Address: 511 Rogers Rd, Toronto, ON M6M 1B4, Canada

Phone: +1 647-358-4800

3. Fresca Pizza and Pasta

Whenever I feel like having pizza, Fresca Pizza and Pasta consistently stands out as one of the best pizza restaurants in Toronto city. Located at 302 College Street, this eatery showcases a diverse menu that champions both pizza and pasta. I find their Margherita pizza particularly noteworthy—with its classic simplicity, it embodies the essence of Italian cuisine. The pizza boasts a thin, crisp crust paired with aromatic basil, delicate smoked mozzarella, and rich tomato sauce—a combination that’s difficult to resist.

The service at Fresca Pizza matches the quality of their food. Staff are attentive, providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere which enhances the dining experience. Whether I'm dining in, taking out, or even inquiring about the menu, my interactions are always met with helpfulness and efficiency.

For those intrigued by pasta, Fresca's array of options complements their pizza selection. The pasta dishes are prepared with an evident commitment to flavor and texture, satisfying the palate with both traditional and innovative creations.

This Vietnamese-owned pizza shop is a testament to Toronto’s culinary diversity. With a coveted Kensington Market location, Fresca Pizza not only serves my favourite pizza but also embodies the spirit of its neighborhood—eclectic, accessible, and full of character.

Contact:

Address: 302 College St, Toronto, ON M5T 1R9, Canada

Phone: +1 416-922-9555

4. The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

I discovered The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria as a gem within Toronto its thriving culinary scene, particularly when pizza is the craving of the hour. Shant Mardirosian, the mind behind the celebrated Burger's Priest, transferred his knack for comfort food to the realm of Italian cuisine, establishing this pizza joint that stands out for its affordability without compromising quality.

The pizza landscape in Toronto is diverse, but The Fourth Man in the Fire makes a mark with its 18-inch pies that reflect both quality and quantity. The pizza menu might include options like the Vodka Pie, which has become a local favorite. These pizzas are designed to delight various palates, whether you prefer something classic or with a gourmet edge.

When I visited, the atmosphere was casual, perfect for a relaxed dining experience. Yet, it’s not just dine-in that they excel at; for those cozy nights in, their delivery service is reliable and prompt, ensuring that the experience is just as good at home.

There’s been significant chatter about their Detroit-style pizza, which is a nod to the thick, square-cut pies native to the Motor City. Though, as of my last check, their focus seemed to be more on New York-style pizzas.

In essence, this pizza spot in Toronto caters to those looking for a satisfying meal that feels both familiar and indulgent, without breaking the bank. It's not just a meal; it's an experience that echoes the founder's commitment to quality and value in Toronto's gastronomic tapestry.

Contact:

Address: 832 Dundas St W, Toronto, ON M6J 1V3, Canada

Phone: +1 416-792-3473

5. Blondies Pizza - Ossington

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Blondies Pizza, located on the bustling Ossington strip in Toronto. Known for their signature New York style pizzas, they consistently serve up some top-quality comfort food. As far as I’m aware, Blondies first set up shop in Leslieville in 2018 and has since become a prominent gastronomic fixture in the city.

Their menu comprises a delightful selection of pizzas topped with a variety of choice ingredients that cater to diverse palates. From my experience, their combination of traditional techniques with innovative flavors has garnered a loyal following. Despite maintaining a classic approach to their pies, Blondies isn’t afraid to introduce something novel to their menu—keeping the dining experience fresh and exciting.

As someone who appreciates convenient dining options, I find their takeout service to be particularly commendable. It allows customers to enjoy their offerings from the comfort of their own homes without compromising on the quality of the meal. With a rating of 4.7 on Uber Eats and an address easy to find at 88 Ossington Ave, it seems I’m not the only one who favors Blondies for a slice of gourmet pizza.

In sum, their dedication to creating an enjoyable and high-quality pizza experience is evident from the care they put into each dish. From the ambiance of their location to the exceptional service and mouthwatering pizzas, This spot on Ossington stands out as a must-visit spot for pizza aficionados in Toronto.

Contact:

Address: 88 Ossington Ave Unit 2, Toronto, ON M6J 2Z4, Canada

Phone: +1 437-341-1555

6. Descendant Pizza

Descendant Detroit Style Pizza is recognized as Toronto's original purveyor of Detroit-style pies, and my visit confirmed their reputation. Their location at 1168 Queen St East in downtown Toronto stands out with its unique offerings that reflect the distinct characteristics of square pizzas synonymous with Detroit.

The crust of Descendant's pizzas is a marvel—crispy and airy, with a delightful caramelized cheese perimeter that speaks to the authenticity of the Detroit-style pizza. I noted an array of creative toppings which allows for a rich variety of flavors. One of their notable offerings is the 8 Mile Detroit Style Pizza. It is a homage to the classic Detroit pizza with a touch of innovation that could easily please traditionalists and adventurers alike.

As for the ambiance, Descendant maintains a cozy dine-in space until 9 pm and continues with delivery and takeout options until 10 pm from Tuesday to Sunday. The dedication of the Descendant team to craft and ingredients is apparent in every pizza slice. Their emphasis on quality was palpable from the fresh taste of the top-notch toppings to the rich, melty cheese and the robust sauce that carried a perfect balance of sweetness and tang.

The experience at this East-End spot is about savoring a slice of Detroit in the heart of Toronto, and I understand why locals would line up for this gastronomic gem.

Contact:

Address: 1168 Queen St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1L4, Canada

Phone: +1 647-347-1168

7. Maker Pizza – Chinatown

When I mention Maker Pizza located at 59 Cameron Street in Toronto's vibrant Chinatown, I'm pointing you towards a spot renowned for its delightful pizza offerings. This pizza chain stands out for mastering the blend of traditional techniques with a modern twist on flavors.

Maker Pizza, owned by chef Matty Matheson, is recognized for its impeccable wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas, a testament to their dedication towards authenticity. The menu boasts a variety of options that cater to pizza lovers with different tastes, balancing classic pizza and innovative toppings.

At Maker Pizza, one can find engaging pizza makers that are always ready to assist with menu selections or accommodate special requests. Their approach to service is straightforward and friendly, ensuring customers have a pleasant experience with every visit.

As I explore the Toronto pizza scene, this Toronto pizza place consistently ranks high for their quality. With fresh ingredients and a meticulously maintained wood-fired oven, they are committed to delivering what many claim to be some of the best pizzas in the city. Whether it's the fan-favorite Real Pep God, the Napoli Dynamite, or a customized creation, the flavors come alive with each bite.

I regard Maker Pizza as a must-visit for anyone in search of top-tier pizza in Toronto. The Chinatown location is not only about the food but the ambiance that makes each dining experience there truly special.

Contact:

Address: 59 Cameron St, Toronto, ON M5T 2H1, Canada

Phone: +1 416-782-2000

8. Superpoint

My visit to Superpoint revealed it as a standout among the bustling Toronto pizza scene. Their take on the pepperoni pizza caught my eye, boasting a refreshing execution that diverges nicely from the classic style. Their crust is crispy on the bottom and chewy in just the right way, a perfect foundation for the well-seasoned sauce and cheese.

The highlight at Superpoint for me, is the care they put into selecting their pepperoni. It's clear they prioritize quality, ensuring their pepperoni has the right balance of spice and zest, contributing to an overall flavor profile that is complex and satisfying.

I was also impressed with their attention to the overall dining experience. The ambiance is cozy yet vibrant, providing an ideal setting whether you're grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a meal with friends. In terms of service, my experience was nothing short of exemplary; the team was attentive without being overbearing.

Their commitment to top quality ingredients and an enjoyable dining ambiance makes Superpoint a must-visit for any pizza aficionado in Toronto. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it's worth stopping by to experience their take on pepperoni pizza.

Contact:

Address: 184 Ossington Ave, Toronto, ON M6J 2Z7, Canada

Phone: +1 416-519-6996

9. One Night Only Pizza

When I talk about One Night Only Pizza, I'm referring to a renowned pizza spot located at 581 Pape Avenue in Toronto, Ontario. From my experience, this establishment has carved out a name for itself with its exceptional pizza offerings, consistently receiving positive remarks from diners. They offer a selection of pan pizzas, which have that delightful combination of a crispy crust and a soft, chewy center that pizza connoisseurs often seek.

I've noted that their operating hours are tailored for those evening pizza cravings, making them an excellent choice for dinner plans. Although One Night Only advertises as "unclaimed" on platforms like Yelp, it’s hardly unnoticed by the locals. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a whole pie, they've got you covered.

I've always appreciated the straightforwardness of their menu. It's focused on providing an authentic pizza experience without overwhelming customers with too many options. It's this simplicity, combined with the quality of their ingredients and the execution of their pan pizzas, that keeps me and many others returning to One Night Only Pizza.

Their pan pizzas, specifically, are a must-try due to their perfect balance between crust and toppings. During my visits, I've observed the consistent care that goes into preparing each pizza, ensuring that every customer gets to enjoy a slice that's hearty and satisfying.

Contact:

Address: 581 Pape Ave, Toronto, ON M4K 3R5, Canada

10. Sugo Toronto

I find that when it comes to Italian comfort food in Toronto, Sugo is an establishment that consistently comes up in conversation. Located in the bustling Bloorcourt neighborhood, Sugo serves a variety of Italian-American classics that harken back to the simplicity and heartiness of traditional fare.

Sugo's pizza incorporates high-quality ingredients such as buffalo mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes, both acclaimed for their superior taste and authenticity. These tomatoes, specifically, are known for their sweet flavor and low acidity, making them an ideal base for pizza sauce.

The ambiance of this Italian restaurant is casual and inviting, matching the comfort evoked by their dishes. With its reputation for flavor-packed plates and a laid-back dining experience, it’s easy to see why Sugo is a celebrated spot among Toronto’s extensive selection of pizzerias.

Contact:

Address: 1281 Bloor St W, Toronto, ON M6H 1N7, Canada

Phone: +1 416-535-1717